Click here to stay in the archives
Click here to go back to ProFootballWeekly.com
"In our opinion" daily columns

Monday, Feb. 4, 2002

MVP voters get it wrong, again

Patriots CB Ty Law should have won the Super Bowl MVP honors, not Brady

By Andy Hanacek, Associate editor

Wow! Nothing, and I mean, nothing, beats a great Super Bowl finish, especially when more than 75 percent of the populace is expecting a super blowout.

Personally, I enjoyed the game last night, and I would’ve enjoyed it either way, whether the Rams or Patriots won, because of the closeness of the game. I don’t mind when the team I’m rooting for loses the Super Bowl if the game is close. If they lose in exciting fashion, well, at least it was exciting.

So, in the end, we all know what happened to make things exciting. The Patriots drove into field-goal position with time ticking away and Adam Vinatieri knocked the game-winner through from 48 yards out as time expired.

During the postgame ceremony, Fox’s Terry Bradshaw announced the game MVP award in pathetic, commercialized fashion. QB Tom Brady was given the keys to a new Cadillac piece-of-junk SUV (all SUVs are pieces of junk, in my opinion…not just Cadillacs).

Brady seemed stunned, asking if that really was his car. Meanwhile, I was stunned, asking if what I had just heard really happened. Brady won the MVP? Really? What did I miss?

For the second year in a row, the MVP voters (whoever they may be) picked the wrong guy. Last year, in the biggest kiss-and-make-up move in history, Ravens MLB Ray Lewis was awarded the game MVP honors, after a week of pregame media tormenting, despite a fairly average performance in the game as well as excellent performances by the other two Lewises on the team, Jamal and Jermaine.

This season, Brady gets the honors based on the fact that he was the quarterback who led his team 53 yards in 1:21 to the game-winning field-goal attempt. It had to be based solely on that fact, because, truth be told, Brady didn’t do that much to impress me the entire game aside from keeping his composure.

Certainly, Brady played well — I can’t deny that fact. But was it an MVP performance? No. Was he a key reason the Patriots stunned the world and outdueled the Rams? Definitely not. Sure, Brady didn’t throw an interception the whole game and he did have a spectacular TD pass to David Patten. But completing 16-of-27 passes for 145 yards is far from an MVP performance.

At worst, Vinatieri deserved it for kicking the game-winner. But, in my opinion, Vinatieri shouldn’t get it either. It should have gone to CB Ty Law.

Look at what Law did in this game, besides the fact that he returned an easy pick for a 47-yard touchdown in the second quarter. Law led the team in total tackles with eight, followed by S Lawyer Milloy, who had seven. Milloy, Law, CB Otis Smith and the rest of the secondary roughed up the Rams’ receivers continuously and created all three takeaways for the Patriots (two interceptions and a fumble on a hit by S Antwan Harris on Rams WR Ricky Proehl).

If the league kept with the Patriots’ mantra of "team" heading into this game, then maybe it would have given the Patriots’ secondary the game MVP honors. But the league would not do that, and really, it shouldn’t. But it should follow its own voting tradition in games where no one stands out.

In Super Bowl XXXV, when Ray Lewis was awarded the game MVP honors, many of those who defended the choice said it was a symbolic award given to the leader of the Ravens’ defense, which dominated the game.

Law should be driving that SUV today, not Brady.

vertical_bar.gif (672 bytes)

The Archives
2001 - 2002 Season

Online writers — features and columns by our PFW staff, columnists, national correspondent, AFC reporters, NFC reporters and contributing writers
College football — articles, college notepad, key college game previews, PFW's college top 10, Scouting Combine, Senior Bowl, top 25 predictions
Fantasy football — articles, injury reports, weekly fantasy tips, weekly matchups, The Fantasy Doctor, "In our opinion" daily fantasy columns, Fantasy spins
Free-agency — news and notes, updates and features
General features — Internet features, features from our print edition, MVP meter, Rookie meter, They said it, team reports, training camp reports
Handicapper's Corner — staff selections, games of the week, PFW Players of the Week, NFL standings, weekly handicapping columns, predictions, trends, tips and timely stats
"In our opinion" daily columns — opinions on general football topics
"PFW spins" — short-takes on current events
Joel Buchsbaum — college player evaluations, NFL player analysis, NFL draft coverage, NFL notepad, NFList, college game previews and other NFL articles by PFW's contributing editor
NFL Draft — player evaluations, printouts, feature stories, commentaries, draft recaps
Ron Pollack — articles and commentary by PFW's editor-in-chief
Season in review  — the 2001-2002 NFL season

 

Thanks for visiting Pro Football Weekly's Archives at archive.profootballweekly.com

Click here to go to ProFootballWeekly.com Click here to return to our main site
ProFootballWeekly.com

© 1998-2002 by Pro Football Weekly, a Primedia publication. All rights reserved. Reproduction without permission is prohibited.