Click here to stay in the archives
Click here to go back to ProFootballWeekly.com

Pro Football Weekly and Riddell present ...
2002 NFL draft

Scouting reports: Linebackers

As published in Pro Football Weekly's 2002 Draft Preview

Quarterbacks|Running backs|Wide receivers|Tight ends
Offensive linemen|Defensive linemen|Linebackers
Defensive backs|Kickers

 

Buchsbaum's top 10
(as of March 11)

1. Napoleon Harris
2. Robert Thomas
3. Levar Fisher
4. Saleem Rasheed
5. Raonall Smith
6. Ben Leber
7. Ben Taylor
8. Rocky Calmus
9. David Thornton
10. Justin Ena

Robert Thomas
Robert Thomas
Editor's note:
E — Height, weight and speed are estimated.
e — Only the 40-yard-dash time is estimated.
On all positions, 40-yard-dash times are curved to take conditions into account. For instance, a 4.4 40 on a very fast rubber track would be recorded as a 4.52, while a 4.6 on slow grass would be logged as a 4.5.

(Players are listed in alphabetical order)

LB Rocky Calmus
(6-3, 243, 4.75e) Oklahoma
Notes: State of Oklahoma Defensive Player of the Year in high school, when he weighed slightly more than 200 pounds. Second-team freshman All-American in 1998, when he was in on 55 stops, including 11 for loss and one sack. Associated Press All-Big 12, Coaches’ second-team All-Conference, team’s top tackler, Academic All-Conference and Defensive MVP in ’99, when he played in every game and started 11 times. Only non-start was because of a broken bone in his leg, but he still played in that game. Had 114-14-4, his first interception and seven passes broken up. Consensus All-American and a Butkus Award finalist in 2000, when he started the opener in the middle. Calmus started from Game Two on at weak-side linebacker. Had 125-17-4. Picked off a pass and returned it 41 yards for a touchdown against Texas. Broke up eight passes, caused three fumbles and recovered three fumbles. Had 17 tackles in both the Nebraska and Texas A&M games. All-American and the most decorated linebacker in the nation as a senior. Was a Nagurski and Bednarik finalist and the Butkus Award winner in ’01, when he had 117-15-4. Also broke up 11 passes and picked off one.

Positives: Great intangibles and work ethic. A coach’s dream. Very instinctive. A see-the-ball-and-run-to-it-type linebacker who makes plays and plays very hard. Good key and diagnose and has a great motor. Shows awareness in pass coverage. Very productive in college. A leader. Has gotten bigger and stronger.

Negatives: Lacks great bulk strength and power. Does not take on and shed blocks that well. Gets bounced around at times and is not powerful enough to step up and really stack the run. Lacks explosiveness and is just an above-average athlete. May not be strong enough to play in the middle alone or on the strong side over a tight end unless he is protected. Is not as quick, nimble and athletic as teams would like on the weak side and has some trouble with man-on-man coverage.

Summary: Terrific college player with great intangibles who should make it in the NFL and contribute, but he is not a top prospect because of his limitations.

Top of page

LB Justin Ena
(6-2 7/8, 248, 4.85e) Brigham Young
Notes: Three-sport letterman (football, baseball and basketball) in high school. Enrolled in the spring of 1997 and redshirted that fall. Lettered in ’98. Second-team All-Mountain West Conference pick in ’99 and a first-team selection in 2000, when he led the team in tackles with 107 after replacing Rob Morris at inside linebacker. His 107 tackles included 11 for loss and three sacks. Ena also broke up four passes and caused three fumbles. In 2001, Ena had a team-high 101 tackles, including 11 for loss and three sacks, did not pick off a pass and broke up three while earning All-MWC honors.

Positives: Excellent size. Good athlete. Fits the mold size-wise and is really well put together. Tough, competitive and intense. Vocal team leader. Special-teamer’s personality. Likes to play.

Negatives: Does not play with really good leverage and has a hard time shedding blocks. Lacks anticipation and feel. Slow to locate the ball. Must see the play unfold before he can react. Does not appear to have a good feel for pass coverage. Slightly overaged. Will turn 25 in November.

Summary: Big, tough linebacker who lacks great natural instincts, but he has some tools to work with and is a competitor and warrior.

Top of page

LB Levar Fisher
(6-0 7/8, 233, 4.66) North Carolina State
Notes: Started the last eight games of the 1998 season as a true freshman and every game since then. Won All-Atlantic Coast Conference honors and some All-America honors in ’01, when he was in on a team-best 148 tackles, including three for loss, 1 1/2 sacks and two passes broken up, despite playing with a bad knee since Game Five. However, he broke his left arm (non-displaced fracture of the large bone near his elbow) in North Carolina State’s bowl game. All-ACC and ACC Defensive Player of the Year, Football Writers of America All-American and a Bronko Nagurski finalist in 2000, when he led the ACC in tackles with 166, including 15 for loss and five sacks. Also broke up eight passes and picked off one. Had 74 tackles, three for loss, two sacks and four passes broken up as a freshman; and 104 tackles, including 12 for loss, 3 1/2 sacks and one pass broken up in ’99. Missed spring practice in ’01 after having shoulder surgery, which also prevented him from doing the type of work he had been doing in the weight room, where he had bench-pressed more than 450 pounds and squatted more than 500.

Positives: Extremely productive college football player who has been durable. Very active and has good instincts. Plays fast and can be explosive. Always seems to be around the ball. Plays hard and competes well.

Negatives: Undersized. Is more of a run-around rather than take-on-type linebacker and will get engulfed by bigger blockers at times. Does not turn that fluidly in coverage or have a great feel in zone coverages. Better hitter than tackler and, at times, will miss some tackles because he goes for the kill instead of wrapping up. Will be coming off a fractured left forearm and a knee scope in ’02.

Summary: A terrific college football player who is small for the pros, but he still should be a solid NFL player, provided that he is healthy and goes to a team that uses a scheme that does not ask him to take on the blockers very often and gives him a chance to run to the ball.

Top of page

OLB-DE Napoleon Harris
(6-2 7/8, 255, 4.58) Northwestern
Notes: Top high school football and basketball player, who in football generally lined up at defensive end and was turned loose to create havoc and rarely had much responsibility or many assignments other than to make plays. Football redshirt at Northwestern in 1997 but joined the basketball team after the season and averaged 4.9 points per game and also got a number of rebounds in the 18 games in which he played. Played in every football game in ’98 and had 32 stops, including two for loss and one interception. Moved into the starting lineup at outside ’backer in ’99. In 10 games had 110 stops, including five for loss, three sacks and broke up five passes. Started every game in 2000, although he had to play the last two games with a cast on his hand after breaking it against Michigan. Had 101 stops, including 13 for loss, three sacks, picked off two passes, broke up six and was a second-team All-Big Ten pick. Moved to rush defensive end when nobody else could do the job in ’01. Started every game and had 78 stops, including nine for loss and three sacks. Also broke up five passes, picked off one and had 19 QB hurries.

Positives: Very good athlete. Plays with excellent game speed, power and passion. Can play over and really control the tight end. Has the quickness to rush off the edge. Fills well. Will hustle and chase. Has sideline-to-sideline range. Big hitter with a touch of nasty. Likes to punish the man with the ball. Has good hands, which are very big, for catching the ball. Can turn and run with people in pass coverage. Prepares well, watches film and plays with confidence.

Negatives: Did not have a great senior year, although in fairness to Harris, it should be pointed out he was playing out of position. Is not a natural pass defender and is not as instinctive vs. the pass as he is against the run. Looks a little stiff in coverage and does not have fluid hips. Will get wired to the blocker at times and does not always use his hands well.

Summary: If he is not the top linebacker taken, he will be one of the first to go. Has almost everything scouts are looking for in an outside linebacker and could be a great 3-4 ’backer if he goes to a team like the Steelers.

Top of page

LB Ben Leber
(6-3, 244, 4.68) Kansas State
Notes: Parade All-American from South Dakota. Also was a sprinter in high school. Redshirted in 1997. Lettered in ’98. Had 30 tackles, 10 tackles for loss and two sacks, despite starting just once. Started the past three years. Played in the middle in ’99 and had 58-7-2. Also broke up three passes. Moved to the strong side in 2000 and had 55-14-3 1/2. Also broke up two passes and won second-team All-Big 12 honors. Had his most productive year in ’01, recording 73-15-6. Won first-team All-Big 12 honors from the Associated Press and the league’s coaches.

Positives: Excellent intangibles. Great worker. Very smart and disciplined. Tries to do everything the way it is coached. Studies tape for tendencies. Runs well and has good range. Uses hands pretty well to shed blockers and control the tight end. Generally plays the game on his feet.

Negatives: Is a good athlete who works out well but on tape looks a little stiff and straight-linish at times and does not have great change of direction or feet. Lacks top explosiveness and is not a great take-on type of linebacker. Prefers to run around blockers. Is very smart and prepares well but lacks great instincts and reaction speed. Seems to think instead of just reacting at times. Plays hard but is no killer.

Summary: A good player with a great work ethic who lacks special physical qualities in some areas and is not superinstinctive. Can become a solid pro if he can improve in some areas but may lack the intuitiveness and explosiveness to be a special player.

Top of page

LB Saleem Rasheed
(6-2 5/8, 229, 4.6e) Alabama
Notes: Third-year junior who opted to come out early. Former high school All-American. Started every game as a true freshman, with most of his action coming at "Sam" linebacker and 2 1/2 games at middle linebacker. Led the Tide in tackles. Was named the SEC Defensive Freshman of the Year and won Freshman All-America honors. Moved to the weak side in 2000 and started the first 10 games but did not start vs. Auburn. Started every game in the middle in ’01, led the team in tackles and was named to the coaches’ All-SEC team. Had 84 stops, including eight for loss and three sacks, one pass broken up and no interceptions in 1999, 81-4-0-1-0 in 2000 and 114-7-2-5-0 in ’01.

Positives: Very good athlete. Quick and active with the speed to run plays down. Instinctive vs. the run. Has been durable and productive. Versatile enough to have started at all three LB positions. Tough and competitive. Should do well on special teams. Very good weight-room numbers and is very strong pound-for-pound in the weight room. Reportedly can bench-press close to 500 pounds, which is more than twice his body weight, and handle more than 400 pounds on the incline press.

Negatives: Lacks great size. Is not really big enough to be a true "Mike" or "Sam" linebacker in the NFL. Gets knocked down a lot and blocked in the middle when he tries to take on blocks instead of running around them. Takes himself out of some plays when he runs around. Has not been very productive in coverage and may lack a good feel for it. Also looks a little stiff at times.

Summary: A very good football player but may not be a great fit at any of the LB positions unless he gets a lot more natural in coverage. In that case, he would make an excellent "Will" ’backer.

Top of page

OLB Raonall Smith
(6-2, 242, 4.53) Washington State
Notes: Has run 4.49 on a very, very fast surface. Three-sport (football, basketball and baseball) athlete in high school who graduated in 1996. Delayed collegiate enrollment until January of ’97 to save a year, but still wound up redshirting in ’97. Was limited to six games and two starts in ’98 because of injuries. Had surgery on his shoulder after the year. Played in eight games and started four in ’99 and missed three games with a knee injury and one with a shoulder injury. Stayed healthy and started every game in 2000. However, missed time in ’01 when he had his knee scoped on Oct. 1. Nevertheless, only missed one full game and two starts and was a second-team All-Pacific-10 pick. Had 26 tackles, including six for loss, and two sacks in ’98. Was in on 38 tackles, including four for loss, in ’99. Had 71 stops, including 12 for loss, and three sacks in ’00 and also broke up five passes. Took part in 68 tackles, including seven for negative yardage in ’01, picked off his first pass and broke up a half-dozen passes.

Positives: Looks the part. Has a great body. Is very athletic and has tremendous speed and jumping ability. Runs like a deer and jumps like a kangaroo. Can be an explosive hitter. Can make plays sideline to sideline and blitz off the edge. At times, does a terrific job in coverage and looks natural. Can run with receivers and backs and blanket tight ends. Should make an excellent special-teams player.

Negatives: Hot and cold player whose lack of football instincts and experience often handicap him. Can do everything you would want an outside linebacker to do, but does not do anything well on a consistent basis. Late reactor who generally needs to see things unfold before he can react. Will let the play-action fake freeze him. Has too much indecision in his play. Lacks awareness against the pass and at times will look a little lost. Has a hard time coming off blocks. When he gets blocked against the run or when blitzing, he tends to stay blocked. Has not been that durable.

Summary: Great workout guy who flashes all the tools, but unless the light goes on and he really starts to see the big picture, he will be a player that looks like Tarzan and runs like a deer, but does not get enough done. Is a lot like Mark Fields was, but not as nasty, aggressive or explosive.

Top of page

LB Ben Taylor
(6-1 3/8, 238, 4.83) Virginia Tech
Notes: Had shoulder surgery in high school and sat out the fall semester in 1997. Enrolled in January ’98 to save a year of eligibility. Had 23 tackles as a backup and on special teams in ’98. Started every game at outside linebacker in ’99 and had 71 tackles, five tackles for loss and one sack. Moved to inside linebacker in 2000 (team uses an outside, inside and middle linebacker) and led the team in tackles with 103-5-1 1/2. Also had five passes broken up, intercepted two passes and punted three times for a 33.7-yard average with a long of 42 yards and one inside the 20. Was an All-Big East pick and one of 11 semifinalists for the Butkus Award (nation’s top linebacker). In ’01, Taylor had a team-best 121 tackles and 18 tackles for loss, tied for the team sack lead with 4 1/2, picked off one pass and broke up two. Was a first-team All-Big East pick and earned some All-America notice.

Positives: Top competitor with excellent intangibles. Prepares well, pays attention to the little things and knows the defense. Is a very active and instinctive player who has a motor that is going 100 mph. Makes plays. Catches the ball very well and has done some punting.

Negatives: Lacks size and strength at the point of attack and can’t step up, shed and fill like scouts would like. Playing strength may always be a problem because of the way he is built (narrow without a good powerbase).

Summary: An active, instinctive and productive player who lacks size and must be protected by those in front of him to be effective.

Top of page

MLB Robert Thomas
(6-0, 233, 4.55) UCLA
Notes: Former high school All-American in football who also was a top prep baseball player. Father was a pro baseball player in the 1960s, and one of his older brothers, Stan, was a starting offensive tackle at Texas and the Bears’ first-round pick in ’91. Robert played as a true freshman in ’98, when he had 26 stops, including two for loss, and blocked a punt. In ’99, he played in and started eight of the last nine games. He missed the first two games and later in the year he sat out the Arizona game with a concussion suffered the previous week. Thomas started in 2000 and played with a stress fracture in his left foot. Had 80 stops, including eight for loss and caused six fumbles, but he did not have a sack, interception or pass broken up. Nevertheless, was a second-team All-Pacific-10 pick and was named UCLA’s Defensive MVP. In ’01, after dropping weight, Thomas had, by far and away, his best year. He had 111-26 and 6 1/2 sacks, and he broke up five passes. As a result, he was a consensus All-American and the Pac-10’s Defensive Player of the Year.

Positives: Showed phenomenal improvement in ’01 after losing weight. Great effort guy who plays all-out all the time. Does the extras (film study, weight room) off the field as well. Has a passion for game. Good athlete. Very quick, fast and active. Flows to the ball well and takes good pursuit angles versus the run. Has a short-area burst of speed and can be an explosive hitter. Quick to read and react. Anticipates well and knows when to gamble.

Negatives: Lacks size as a middle linebacker at 230 but loses something when he adds weight. Needs to be protected, or the big blockers will smother him. Is much more of a run-around-the-blocker type than a take-on-and-shed player. Needs work on pass coverage.

Summary: An exceptional college player and a very good pro prospect whose lack of size will hurt him on the next level. May have to move to the weak side unless he is in a 3-4 scheme or plays for a team such as the Dolphins, who have giant-sized tackles to protect him and let him just run to the ball.

Top of page

OLB David Thornton
(6-1 3/4, 236, 4.68) North Carolina
Notes: Former walk-on. Was used at safety and on special teams in 1999, when he had a hand in eight tackles. Moved to outside linebacker in 2000 and was a backup and special-teams player. Got a scholarship in the spring of ’01 and really earned it in the fall. Stood out from the Oklahoma game on and finished the year with a team-best 131 tackles, including 10 for loss and three sacks. Also broke up five passes and picked off one.

Positives: Showed dramatic improvement in ’01. Very productive football player. Very active and instinctive. Quick to read and react. Has a good feel for pass coverage and a knack for avoiding blockers. Solid tackler. Was the defensive MVP on a team with Julius Peppers and Ryan Sims.

Negatives: Lacks great size. At times will struggle a little to change directions. Is not fluid turning and has some stiffness. Is not very good at taking on and defeating blockers and is much better when uncovered.

Summary: Came on like gangbusters as a senior and was bigger and faster at the Combine than he ever had been in the past.

Top of page

You'll find profiles of 54 more linebackers in the print edition of Pro Football Weekly's Draft Preview 2002 book. It's available at bookstores and newsstands across the country or you can call 1-800-FOOTBALL (1-800-366-8225) to order a copy. To order online, click here

The Archives
2001 - 2002 Season

Online writers — features and columns by our PFW staff, columnists, national correspondent, AFC reporters, NFC reporters and contributing writers
College football — articles, college notepad, key college game previews, PFW's college top 10, Scouting Combine, Senior Bowl, top 25 predictions
Fantasy football — articles, injury reports, weekly fantasy tips, weekly matchups, The Fantasy Doctor, "In our opinion" daily fantasy columns, Fantasy spins
Free-agency — news and notes, updates and features
General features — Internet features, features from our print edition, MVP meter, Rookie meter, They said it, team reports, training camp reports
Handicapper's Corner — staff selections, games of the week, PFW Players of the Week, NFL standings, weekly handicapping columns, predictions, trends, tips and timely stats
"In our opinion" daily columns — opinions on general football topics
"PFW spins" — short-takes on current events
Joel Buchsbaum — college player evaluations, NFL player analysis, NFL draft coverage, NFL notepad, NFList, college game previews and other NFL articles by PFW's contributing editor
NFL Draft — player evaluations, printouts, feature stories, commentaries, draft recaps
Ron Pollack — articles and commentary by PFW's editor-in-chief
Season in review  — the 2001-2002 NFL season

 

Thanks for visiting Pro Football Weekly's Archives at archive.profootballweekly.com

Click here to go to ProFootballWeekly.com Click here to return to our main site
ProFootballWeekly.com

© 1998-2002 by Pro Football Weekly, a Primedia publication. All rights reserved. Reproduction without permission is prohibited.